I dont think harry potter and the deathly hallows part 2 overall is better than the book for me, none of the movies have ever reached that mark but these 10 individual moments definitely are. Below are a list of changes made to the stories of the harry potter books when they were adapted. Sirius black has a prison tattoo in the movies that did not exist in the books. Let me preface this by saying that harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban is my favorite book of the entire series. Most of these differences include characters and scenes.
In the film, snape invades harrys mind during the occlumency lessons, but when harry turns the tables on him and reads snap. Throughout the entire book series and movies, the dursleys are terrible to harry. Whether because they split the final book in half or its just one of the easiest to translate to the screen, harry potter and the deathly hallows part 1 is the movie most loyal to the book its. They blame him for everything and shun his magical ability, so its not surprising that they are widely disliked. The way harry, ron, and hermione all meet is basically the same, except the dialogue is a little different. Its 2018over 10 years since the book release of harry potter and the deathly hallowsand there is hardly a shortage of diehard harry potter fans. This post is a comparison of major plot points in the movie and book versions of harry potter and the deathly hallows pt.
Compare contrast harry potter movie and book free essays. This movie was based off the bestselling novel, which was written in 1997 by j. However, the movies skipped over dudleys one moment of redemption. A month later, in october, the students from beauxbaton and durmstrang arrive in preparation the goblet of fire. While most fans appreciate the books and the movies for their respective merits, there are plenty of book fans who think the movies did a fairly poor job of representing the intricacy and beauty of. Therefore, after finishing the book, i decided to have that experience again through watching the harry potter movie, written by j. Movie harry will tell movie ron to do something that ron volunteered to do in the books. Jul 30, 1997, harry potter and the sorcerers stone book published. List of differences between the harry potter books and. Rowling still captivates wizardry fans with her fantastic beasts franchise. Rowling brought us the world of harry potter and endowed it with an impressive number of secrets. Hollywood cares more about the celebrity than the character. Nov 8, 2005, harry potter and the goblet of fire movie release. Harry potter and the order of the phoenix ive read the book, ive seen the movie, now heres the differences obviously, this is one big spoiler fest, so youre been warned.
If the characters of harry potter looked like they did. So, when the prisoner of azkaban movie was released 10 years ago on june 4. At least, thats the glass halffull way to look at it. Harry potter and the order of phoenix has a lot a lot a lot of differences between the movie and the book as the books grew larger and the movies were still under 3 hours, a lot of compromises were done and a lot of stories were shaved off.
Though its been years since the last harry potter book and movie were released, j. Another significant difference between the first book and movie is how harry potter meets and interacts with draco malfoy for the first time. Some she only revealed after the last book had been written, some are found by fans, and some arent hidden at all. The book harry potter and the sorcerers stone differs from the movie harry potter and the sorcerers stone in many ways. List of differences between the harry potter books and films harry. In the movie, no one cares that harry potter the boy who lived and kicked some serious ass is. Thanks to the very talented band of harry potter filmmakers, the books and the movies are two very different beasts. No booktofilm adaptation is perfect, but for a long time, harry potter fans have felt that the philosophers stone was the closest to perfect that fandom got.
Also ron is extremely tactical and shows it in the first bookmovie with the chessboard game. First harry potter series, the sorcerers stone was released in 1997 and eighth one the deathly hallow was released in 2011. The two ways to discover this harry potter adventure are to either read the book or watch the movie. When it comes to harry, i love them both but there are a lot of details left out if you only see the movie. The film was loved by fans, but deviated from the source material. I am an avid harry potter fan, and i obviously love the movies too. Are you more of a harry potter book person or movie person. Harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban book and movie differences were adding in differences as we find them, but if you notice that weve left something out, please email us at corrections. In the book, harrys eyes are green while in the movie they are blue. Rowlings beloved harry potter books kicked off their. In the movie, ron and hermione kiss in the chamber of secrets instead of in front of harry, which was a glorious scene in the books because. Harry potter books and movie release dates timeline.
Harry and rons return to friendship is a bit more strained than depicted in the book, and it occurs in the gryffindor common room, not the first aid tent professor mcgonagall teaches the. At that moment when the last movie came out, harry potter series became the second highest grossing film of all time. No book tofilm adaptation is perfect, but for a long time, harry potter fans have felt that the philosophers stone was the closest to perfect that fandom got. The harry potter movies have their benefits, but most book fans would rather be reading. Harry potter has a surprising number of kisses we all looked forward to when we made the journey to the theater. A lot of little moments where ron defends harry are omitted. Ive read the books countless times mostly because i was to embarrassed to keep count over 30, and one of the most serious forms of punishment i received when i was a kid was when my mom threatened to take away my harry potter books. After years of tormenting harry, dudley shows some sign of remorse when he. Harry potter and the philosophers stone was the first movie book in the franchise. The harry potter series changed things in a way few imagined they would, be it c. Despite loving the harry potter books and overall preferring them to the movie, the movie versions of the characters, their personalities, and their mannerisms at times fight and win the battle.
I dont know about you all, but harry potter and the chamber of secrets is totally one of my favorite movies in the magical series, and it also happens to be one of my favorite books in j. Harry potter is one of the most wildly successful franchises in existence. He was particularly fond of his mistress walburga black, who died in 1985, but whose portrait still shrieked orders from the wall in the front hall of the black house. Dumbledore uses his deluminator 5 times in the film however in the book he clicks it 12 times. Here are some, from harry potter and the sorcerers stone. While i didnt expect to be first in line for the final harry potter movie, at 11 p. This means that if youve only ever seen the films and never read the books or vice versa you may find it interesting to see how the harry potter stories change before your eyes as rapidly as a hogwarts staircase.
Read more about harry potter and try our prisoner of azkaban book quiz or our prisoner of azkaban. Harry potter book and movie comparison essay example. Comparative analysis harry potter books vs movies yuri. Differences between harry potter and the half blood prince. The hogwarts student return to school in september.
Also, one of the biggest things that are different is the the book is called harry potter and the philosophers stone and the movie is called harry potter and the sorcerers stone. Harrys first crush came with an abundance of teen angst. Reading a book gives you so much more detail on the story or subject, and you can let your mind and imagination wander. Kreacher was a male houseelf who served the house of black with fanatical loyalty for most of his life, until he was left to harry potter upon the death of sirius black in 1996. Harry potter and the goblet of fire that was not in the book. Harry potter and the deathly hallows, chapter 36, the flaw in the plan dumbledore had similar plan and it did not work out very well. Harry potter and the philosophers stone was the first moviebook in the franchise. Alas, when the potter movies got the movie treatment, adhering to the. When i was 11, i read harry potter and the sorcerers stone for the first time.
It doesnt take as much time and you get to the point a lot quicker. Harry potter and the half blood prince book vs movie. On the other side of the coin, this is just another way of saying that there is hardly a shortage of people who still cant forgive the movie adaptations for being so different than the books. The way albus dumbledore is described in the books versus how hes. In the book, harry s eyes are green while in the movie they are blue. There were talks initially of making harry potter and the goblet of fire into two movies since the book is more than 700 pages, but the filmmakers opted instead to cut some of the background. Movie with all the new movies based on books or comics that are out, people wonder why. In the case of the harry potter books and the harry potter movies, the books definitely win the award for being better. In the books, molly weasley had a locket with each of her childrens faces that she wore at all times. Nov 19, 2010, harry potter and the deathly hallows part 1 movie release.
In most cases, people would rather watch a movie than read a book. Eight major misfires in harry potter and the deathly hallows. The book begins in the morning of harry s birthday. For example, despite the fact that the movies are iconic to so many people, some characters dont exactly match their descriptions from the books.
Harry potter and the philosophers stone dudley looked a lot like uncle vernon. Its not that i expect every book moment to be there, but there are so many smaller moments where ron tells malfoy to shove off, defending him from snape, or even telling hermione to lay off harry. The one which most strikes me is how theyve changed snape and made his behaviour over the occlumency lessons seem unfair. However vernon does say that harry is not thankful. I really hoped jk would use this later on maybe during the battle of hogwarts and have ron play commander of some dark wizard catchers and strategize a plan, but i feel like she fell into the lure of having hermione be the stronger one in the group.
Its 2018over 10 years since the book release of harry potter and the deathly. Only after the attack at the world cup does harry write sirius after hermione tells him he should. There are spoilers of major scenes, events and deaths. Jul 15, 2011, harry potter and the deathly hallows part two movie release date. Consequently, i realized many major differences and similarities in the reading and watching of harry potter. For all the potterheads out there, this should prove to be a very short read but for all others, try and bear with me.
In the film harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban, we are of course treated to the marauders map in the flesh, complete with roaming footsteps. If you were to read this book and watch the movie you would find many differences, but the main difference between the two is that the book gives more information to the reader than the movie gives to the. Movie october 16, 20 february 21, 2014 even with small changes to the story, this one is perhaps the movie with the least differences from the book. The story of the boy who lived captivated millions, first as a book series and then later over the course of eight films. The latest release, fantastic beasts 2, has fans longing for the days of the gifted wizard, when the only thing. Vernon says they cared for harry since he was a baby, gave him their good food, and. In the film, who throws a rock through the window of hagrids cottage, hitting harry on the back of the head. What are three big differences between the movie and book. Which are better, the harry potter books or movies. Can you answer these harry potter book vs movie questions. Jul 8, 2000, harry potter and the goblet of fire published.
88 1218 922 674 576 1035 1143 1231 344 87 1214 661 1507 780 1231 984 1237 1167 185 1459 223 775 227 1374 805 1284 301 555 1133 403 1361